Skip to main content

Dallas news organizations embark on year-long family violence series -- but will it accomplish anything?

The Denton Record-Chronicle and the Dallas Morning News are planning on doing a series of stories about domestic violence for the rest of 2014 (more info below). From the articles that were written announcing the series, I'm a little concerned that they're not planning on doing anything different than any other news organization has done -- tell gruesome stories about DV homicides, highlight a prevention program or two and then ignore the topic for another five or 10 years.

In the late 90s and early 2000s, Lori Dorfman at Berkeley Media Studies Group and I led the Reporting on Violence project to encourage reporters to include a solution-oriented (aka public health) approach to crime reporting. 
We wanted reporters to use a different strategy in their stories, their beats, data, etc. We did workshops with the largest metropolitan daily news organizations in the state. (The project was funded by the California Wellness Foundation as part of their 10-year effect to reduce youth violence in the state). Before each workshop, I did an analysis of what crime had occurred v. what the news organization reported. 
For example, in San Jose, CA, home of the San Jose Mercury News, over three months there were 9 homicides, 966 aggravated assaults, and 86 rapes. Because the county had a domestic violence intervention team that included every stakeholder in the county and great data, we knew that about 800 of the aggravated assaults were domestic-violence related. During those same three months, the Mercury News reported on 11 homicides (they included two that occurred outside city limits),  5 aggravated assaults and 5 rapes. None -- zero, zip -- of the stories covering aggravated assault were about domestic violence. 
The editors were quite chagrined at these numbers. Two reporters had already been asking their editors if they could do more reporting on domestic violence. After the workshop, the editors gave them the OK to do a series, for which they won several awards. The reporters then asked their editors if they could report only about domestic violence, i.e., make it a beat, because the data showed them that it was the one type of violence that was causing the most emotional and economic damage in the county. We supported them wholeheartedly. The editors said no. 

That experience, and the last nine years of reporting about ACEs, trauma-informed and resilience-building practices has led me to offer these suggestions to news organizations:

  • Family violence (in fact, all interpersonal violence) needs to be an integral part of a health beat.
  • A solution-oriented approach should be taken with every story.
  • The system that grapples with family violence needs to be analyzed to determine whether it's a trauma-informed system or not.
  • And a hard look at the roots of DV should be taken: i.e., that it starts with children who live in a family with violence -- that they're shaped by that ongoing trauma to become perpetrators and/or victims of family violence themselves. 

From the Denton Record-Chronicle: Tracking deadly domestic violence 

In 2012, 1,144 homicides occurred in Texas. According to the Texas Department of Public Safety, 15 percent of them were committed by a family member. Add in ex-spouses, boyfriends and girlfriends, and the number rises to almost 1 in 4.

These horrific, deeply personal stories often go untold or are forgotten quickly. But for the rest of this year the Denton Record-Chronicle will join The Dallas Morning News in tracking and focusing on domestic violence homicides in Dallas, Denton, Collin and Rockwall counties, in a series called “Deadly Affection.”

The News and the Record-Chronicle will look at the victims and perpetrators in fatal cases, including not just husbands and wives, but nuclear and extended families, as well as same-sex and opposite-sex relationships. We hope to find the details that will tell who these people were, how their relationship developed, the extent, duration and type of violence in their home and how it affected others.

And the Dallas Morning News: Campaigns Aren't Enough to Stop Domestic Violence

Reporters Diane Jennings and Sarah Mervosh will take the lead in monitoring a four-county area — Dallas, Collin, Denton and Rockwall — to catalog the tragedies in which, as Diane writes, “home becomes a crime scene and loved ones become murderers.”

...We could stop asking the wrong questions, such as “Why didn’t she just leave?” and “Why didn’t she press charges?” and “Why did she think he would change?”

The questions we need to ask are things like “Why does he think he’s entitled to ‘own’ another person?” and “Why does anyone think hitting somebody is the way to get what you want?” and “Why can’t he manage his temper? What is he, a baby?”

Actually, no. Those aren't the right questions at all.

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Adv

Add Comment

Comments (0)

Copyright © 2023, PACEsConnection. All rights reserved.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×